⚫️🟡 How the 'Vampire Effect' is Hurting Your Content

The “vampire effect” refers to when an ad’s creative elements—such as humor, world events, celebrity endorsement, or special effects—overshadow the brand or product being promoted.

This can lead viewers to remember the advertisement itself but not the associated brand, killing its effectiveness.

Key Characteristics

1. Overshadowing: The content’s creative aspects become more memorable than the brand.

2. Attention Diversion: Viewers focus on the content’s entertainment value rather than the product.

3. Recall Issues: Audiences remember the advertisement but fail to recall what it was selling.

Examples

• Celebrity Endorsements: A famous personality's presence may eclipse the product, leading to poor brand recall.

• Humorous Advertisements: The humor captures attention, but the brand message is forgotten.

• Special Effects: Visual spectacles draw focus away from the brand's message.

• Cultural/World Issues: There may be something going on in the world that overshadows the product and makes the social media content come off as distasteful.

Research Findings

Studies have demonstrated that while creative advertisements are engaging, they do not always enhance brand recall or purchase intent. For instance, research published in the International Journal of Research in Marketing found that celebrity endorsers can sometimes harm brand recall due to the vampire effect.

Impact on Marketing Effectiveness

1. Reduced Return on Investment (ROI): High production costs may not lead to increased sales if the brand is overshadowed.

2. Missed Branding Opportunities: Failure to establish strong brand associations can weaken brand identity.

3. Potential Brand Confusion: Viewers might attribute the advertisement to a different brand, leading to confusion.

Strategies to Mitigate the Vampire Effect

1. Seamless Integration: Ensure that creative elements naturally incorporate the product or brand.

2. Prominent Branding: Feature brand names and visuals conspicuously throughout the advertisement.

3. Believable Celebrities: Celebrity endorsements need to be plausible. Would that celeb actually use the product? If the answer is no, stay away from the partnership.

4. Balanced Messaging: Align creative aspects with clear and consistent brand messages to reinforce brand identity

Brand Examples

We all remember when Kendall Jenner ended racism with her Pepsi advertisement. 🤦🏻‍♂️

This was a prime example of failing on many fronts. The only benefit to Pepsi is that Kendall Jenner outshined the brand in this.

On the other hand, Tom Holland’s BERO launched this past month and was welcomed with a warm reception. This is due to Holland’s believability as someone on a sober journey. The brand uses Tom’s story about finding sobriety, and it being a catalyst for the brand. You can see — one of his many — podcast appearances below.

Believability combined with in-touch creativity can go a long way toward creating brand-forward content.

Until next week,
Jordan

P.S. If you want to connect on social media, where I share tips throughout the week, follow me on X (Twitter) or Linkedin.

Want me to help you grow your social media?